Chocolate Babka French Toast with Caramelized Banana Creme Anglaise

chocolate babka french toast with caramelized banana creme anglaise inspired by the bongo room in chicago

when my parents and i were in chicago during september 2014, we brunched at the bongo room, where we had a chocolate tower french toast. i actually thought it wasn’t that special (compared to the slightly bizarre but scrumptious pretzel caramel pancake), and i wished there was more chocolate. however, the parentals felt differently. they raved about it all day (and into the next year), even as we rolled out the door (thank you, aforementioned french toast and pancake plus drool-worthy lobster roll benedict).

so, this is my riff off of it. on the menu, it’s described as “chocolate tower french toast: bittersweet chocolate chunk bread filled with maple mascarpone, banana creme brulee sauce, fresh bananas and shaved chocolate.” however, i definitely don’t remember the maple mascarpone, and the sauce wasn’t crisped like a brulee in any way, so i just went with a creme anglaise. i’ve made this with challah and chocolate babka, and while the challah is great, the babka is definitely the more authentic choice. before you read further, i’d like to say that this is inspired by the bongo room version, and is not in any way a perfect replica. i don’t even want it to be; i want it to be better (according to my tastebuds).

i took a half batch of food and wine’s (okay, it’s really grace parsi’s) creme anglaise recipe, and punched it with bananas. sorry for sounding cruel. i was debating mashing bananas and cooking it down to a really intense compote, but i was weary of how that would affect the texture of the creme anglaise. my plan was to taste the puree and see how starchy and grainy it was; if it was smooth enough, i’d just fold it into the creme anglaise. i wasn’t thinking and used a barely yellow banana for my first attempt, which unsurprisingly yielded a lumpy creme anglaise. i was convinced that this method wasn’t going to work, and in a classic case of overthinking, i was even debating making my own banana liqueur. but luckily for my sanity, i tried a super ripe, yellow with brown spots, giraffe-ish banana and pureed the heck out of the caramelized mush before folding it into the creme anglaise and straining it. silky smooth.

since chocolate babka is chocolatey (shocking, i know) and rich, it doesn’t need as much as challah. the babka gets dipped in a mix of cocoa powder, milk (the cocoa and milk get mixed first into a paste so that it’s easier to mix that into the rest of the ingredients), eggs, vanilla and salt. no sugar needed, because again, the babka is sweet enough. if, however, you’re using challah or white bread or something that’s a little healthier (pls don’t go too healthy- what’s the point of having an egg white and whole wheat french toast with a yogurt “creme anglaise?? rant over), i’d suggest adding more sugar and cocoa to the custard, and sprinkling the hot french toast with chocolate (more details on this at the bottom of the post).

so, how is this chocolate babka french toast? dense and chocolatey, almost like a brownie. this is more dessert than breakfast, so it’s definitely more special occasion than everyday breakfast food. the creme anglaise is packed with banana flavor (that caramelization though), and is silky smooth and creamy. it was kind of grey, and i wanted to fix it. but then i realized that it tasted amazing already, so there wasn’t any reason to- especially bc, hello, delicious not gorgeous~. and then bananas and strawberries and almonds on top. the strawberries and almonds were most certainly not on the bongo room version, but the berries cut through some of the sweetness and added a bit of pop visually, and the almonds added crunch not found elsewhere in the dish, so they got the okay to stay.

voila, chocolate babka french toast with caramelized banana creme anglaise! did i mention that the leftovers (toast the french toast, microwave the creme anglaise just until warm but not bubbly, transformers assemble) are bananas?

my fave chocolate-y things on the blog:
Pecan Chocolate Espresso Coffee Cake
Chocolate Chip Cupcakes with Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Frosting
Huckleberry’s Chocolate Chunk Muffins
Joanne Chang’s Chocolate Chip Cookies

b-a-n-a-n-a-s:
Caramel Banana Upside Down Cake
Banana-Chocolate-Coffee Muffins
Bon Appetit’s Best Banana Bread
Banana Muffins with Cream Cheese Frosting

1 year ago: Deep Dish Spinach and Sun-dried Tomato Quiche with Toasted Sesame CrustRant Thursday #3

Chocolate Babka French Toast with Caramelized Banana Creme Anglaise
inspired by The Bongo Room, Chicago
French toast adapted from Sara Moulton, creme anglaise adapted from Grace Parsi via Food & Wine

French Toast
1 cup whole or 2% milk, room temperature
2 T unsweetened cocoa powder
2 eggs, room temperature
2 egg whites, room temperature (use the whites from the creme anglaise)
1/2 tsp vanilla extract
1/4 tsp kosher salt
eight 1/4” thick slices chocolate babka* (I used TJ’s)**

  1. Warm about a third of the milk until it starts to bubble (microwave or stovetop both work). Stir in the cocoa until dissolved. Cool slightly.
  2. Combine the cocoa milk and the rest of the milk. Mix in the eggs, vanilla and salt until completely combined, and the eggs have broken down.
  3. Dip the bread in the custard; let it soak for 1 minute on each side, then cook with butter in a skillet over medium heat on the first side until it looks set- a little matte, and no longer liquidy. Flip. Cook the bottom side until that side is set as well. If you’re not sure if the French toast is done, taste some; if it’s too gooey, just plop it back on your griddle or skillet and cook it until it reaches your desired doneness.

Creme Anglaise***
1 banana, thinly sliced
1 T brown sugar
1 cup half-and-half or whole milk (I used whole milk)
1/2 tsp vanilla extract
1/4 cup granulated sugar
2 egg yolks, room temperature

  1. Caramelize the banana in a large saucepan until it’s a medium shade of brown. Add the brown sugar and cook just until it coats the banana and caramelizes a bit. Transfer to a bowl and mash well. (puree if necessary)
  2. Set a large strainer over a medium bowl and set the bowl in a shallow pan of cold water.
  3. In the same pan, combine the dairy and vanilla; cook over moderately low heat just until small bubbles appear around the rim, about 5 minutes.
  4. In another medium bowl, whisk the sugar and yolks until combined. Whisk in half of the hot milk in a thin stream. Pour the mixture into the saucepan and cook over moderate heat, stirring constantly, until the sauce has thickened slightly, 4 to 5 minutes. Mix in the bananas. Immediately strain into a bowl set in a cold water bath. Serve right away or press plastic wrap onto the surface and refrigerate until chilled.

Assembly

Create a generous moat/pond/lake/ocean of sauce on your plate, depending on how much you love it and how strong your willpower is. Artfully display/stack French toast on top. Garnish as desired, with freshly sliced bananas (freshly sliced so they don’t oxidize), strawberries, chocolate, toasted nuts (there’s chopped almonds used for the photographed batch, but walnuts and macadamia nuts sound fab, too).

**I’ve only had the Trader Joe’s chocolate babka (found near all their tarts and baked goods), and can’t comment on how other ones would taste in this. The TJ’s version is pretty chocolatey and sweet, so you may need to adjust the amount of cocoa/sugar in the French toast custard/dip to account for variances between your babka and the TJ’s one.

**If you’re having trouble tracking down chocolate babka, try Trader Joe’s and Albertson’s. However, you don’t need to use chocolate babka. Challah works fine, though it won’t be as rich. If you use a bread that doesn’t have chocolate baked into it, I’d suggest adding 3-4 T granulated sugar and increasing the cocoa by 1-2 T (for 3-4 T total) for the custard, depending on taste. You may need more custard/dip for the bread, depending on how thick your slices are, how long you let them soak, etc. I’d also recommend adding chopped dark chocolate on top of the hot French toast so that you still get the melty/gooey chocolate factor.

***If you’re lazy and reallllyyyy don’t care about your caloric intake, stir the caramelized banana puree into some melted vanilla ice cream and forgo making the custard. It’s hardcore dessert and not breakfast at this point.

12 Comments

  1. Hahah! I feel like your asterisk end note is speaking directly to me! Hardcore dessert. Yes everyday! 😀 Stumbled on your blog through Brick Kitchen! Nice to meet you, Heather! Great Blog!

    1. haha, glad you can relate to that (; nice to meet you too!

  2. I have a pathological hatred of bananas – but otherwise, this sounds AMAZING. #want

    1. the bananas make the creme anglaise so good! but they can definitely be omitted and you still have a super dreamy sauce :3

  3. Mmmm creme anglaise. Mmmmm chocolate babka. Mmmm caramelized anything! I can't even handle how delicious this sounds Heather <3

    1. thanks megan! let me know how it goes if you try it out (:

  4. Hi-the Smitten Kitchen Cookbook has a great recipe for chocolate babka. It's so good even I, no baker, had good results. I'd bet it's on her blog, too. Be warned, you will want to eat it all in one sitting!

    1. ooh i’ll have to try that out! i love all the recipes i’ve tried via deb before (there was a dijon stew that was amazing and i’m not even a huge fan of meat), so i’m sure i’ll be way too tempted to eat the whole loaf as soon was it comes out of the oven (;

  5. This looks AWESOME, Heather!! I've actually lived in the Chicago area my whole life, yet still have not tried The Bongo Room. I hear they have fantastic cinnamon rolls. Anyways, great job! I love anything with CHOCOLATE. ;P

    1. it’s one of those places you need to visit at least once! the line is kind of a bear, but the food is so good. i haven’t had their cinnamon roll, but if i go back to chicago (no plans to go back soon, but who knows) i’ll have to go back and try that!

  6. Banana creme anglaise sounds like heaven to me!

    1. thanks rebecca! it’s quite heavenly 😊

Leave a Reply