Seared Mushroom Salad

This seared mushroom salad has the most golden, flavorful mushrooms ever, even if you don't use a fancy wild variety (cremini/button is just fine). || Delicious Not Gorgeous

raw mushrooms are gross. they’re reminiscent of cotton and dry and flavorless and i don’t want any part of it. what about mushrooms seared until they’re shriveled into wrinkly, prune-esque versions of themselves? sign me up. great description of seared mushrooms, i know. i want them still, especially since i’ve accepted my grandma status and love prunes. how about this: their flavor concentrates, they darken and turn golden a la the best toasted marshmallow out there, and instead of falling apart into bland, pasty crumbles like they did in their past lives, they become tender and hearty and dare i say meaty. SIGN ME UP.

they also become the stars in this seared mushroom salad. this jumble of produce, croutons and prosciutto is an amalgamation of all the textures i crave when i have salad (admittedly, i usually don’t during fall and winter). there’s crispy (and garlicky!) bread, crunchy toasty nuts and slightly chewy mushrooms accompanied by the smooth slide of salty prosciutto, all atop tender lettuce and plenty of basil, oregano and green onions for that fresh crispness associated with raw veggies. if i’m eating salad when all i want is korean bbq and cozy pasta and soup, then it better be this one.

Seared Mushroom Salad | Delicious Not Gorgeous

1 year ago: Caramelized Onion and Brie Tart, Candied Espresso Walnuts
2 years ago: Eggplant Parm, Zha Jiang Mian
3 years ago: On Toast

Seared Mushroom Salad
adapted slightly from Jonathan Waxman’s A Great American Cook
Serves 8 as a side, 3-4 for a main

2 cups cubed sourdough bread
2 tsp minced fresh rosemary
4 T canola oil
2 cloves garlic, minced
1/4 cup pine nuts, toasted (or walnuts or almonds)
1 lb mixed mushrooms (button, portobello, chanterelles, morels, shiitake, hedgehogs, porcini, etc)
1/4 lb thinly sliced prosciutto, cut into thin 1” long strips (optional)
1 onion, 1/4 minced and the rest chopped
1/4 cup sherry or red wine vinegar
2 green onions, minced
leaves from 2 sprigs oregano or 1/2 tsp dried oregano
5 to 6 cups mixed salad greens
1/2 cup loosely packed basil, chopped

  1. Make the croutons: Place the bread on a baking sheet. Bake at 350F until golden, about 8 to 10 minutes. Toss with rosemary, 2 T oil and garlic.
  2. Cut away rough spots on the mushrooms. Cut into bite-size pieces.
  3. Place the minced onion, vinegar and extra virgin olive oil in a small jar. Cover and shake to emulsify. Add the green onion and oregano; shake.
  4. Toss the greens and basil in a large bowl.
  5. Heat 2 T oil in a large skillet over medium-high heat until almost smoking. Add the mushrooms and remaining onions. Cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms are golden, 5 minutes. Add the vinaigrette, stir well and remove from heat. Immediately add to the greens and toss once. Add the nuts, prosciutto and croutons; toss vigorously. Note: I also added cherry tomatoes but not necessary, especially if it’s winter and there are no good cherry tomatoes to be had. Divide among plates. Serve this seared mushroom salad immediately.

8 Replies to “Seared Mushroom Salad”

  1. I love mushrooms and making them the centre of this salad is such a lovely idea.

    1. thanks! i love mushrooms too and would put them in almost anything savory if i could (;

  2. seared mushrooms are the BEST – fave ways at the moment are on pizza along with caramelised onions + prosciutto, and accompanied by polenta chips and a poached egg! SO good. and YES to the almost meaty! x

    1. oh my, your ideas sound amazing!! how do you make polenta chips? i’m thinking a log of storebought polenta sliced into rounds and then baked/fried until crispy.

  3. My housemate eats them raw and like you I can;t abide it. Where is the flavour?? I like them cooked to the point of caramelisation so this salad looks right up my alley. Omnomnom

    1. maybe that’s the point- there’s no flavor and it’s therefore more mild?! who knows, but i’ll just continue to happily eat my seared, caramelized, delicious mushrooms (;

Leave a Reply